To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Sadly, these are the biggest “extra small” shirts I’ve ever tried on, and definitely the baggiest “slim fit” shirts too. I’m unfortunately not the tallest, or most well built guy on the planet, but I’m usually a true XS in size. These were just massive on me, and I will be returning them.
That being said, however, the quality is excellent. They are very, very well made, and they would definitely be a great lower layer to have on on colder days. I really, really wish they had fitted me better.
If you are lucky enough to be taller than me (which I’m almost certain you are), I would probably recommend considering a size down, as these definitely seem to run large.
Not what I would consider a slim fit compared to other slim fit Amazon branded shirts. This one seems like a one-off (maybe a mislabeled regular fit?) because it's surprisingly loose compared to other Amazon Essentials slim fit shirts.
Quality is quite good though, nice medium weight soft flannel. For the price you can't do any better.
Honestly though I've found the Amazon Essentials slim fit shirts to be inconsistent across styles, so maybe this shouldn't surprise me. The loosest ones are the chambray shirts. I own several of the two pocket flannel long sleeve shirts and they fit noticeably slimmer.
I've found the GoodThreads slim fit shirts to be slightly slimmer and the slimmest fitting overall of the Amazon brands. For example, the GoodThreads Oxford shirts are quite slim and flattering. But I can still wear a shirt under, which is good.
The GoodThreads and Essentials brand shirts are really a great bargain, and the fact that the quality is so good makes it a no-brainer for me. I've gotten to the point where I only buy those brands because I can only seem to find the beer belly fit shirts in the department stores. It's a bonus that they offer all the Amazon brand shirts in both slim and regular fits. Must be a slim fit for me though, I can't stand the beer belly shirts or that loose fit appearance.
Fits one size smaller than usual. I will have to wear it opened with a tshirt underneath, because its tight when buttoned. Sleeve length was appropriate though for its size. If you don't want it to be clingy and tight around the belly order one size larger than usual. It is a normal autumn weight flannel. Seems decent enough for the price.
I love these Amazon Essentials flannels. They are soft, comfortable and sturdy, and at a price that really can't be beat. The shoulders fit exactly as they should and would be considered true to size. But I really don't know what kind of slenderman they use to figure out their body length because I have bought two of these and they are both way too long, as in the bottom of the shirt goes below your crotch area. I prefer wearing my flannels untucked and I can't with these which is a real shame because I love everything else about them.