To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
The fabric and design of this shirt is of really good quality. Not the cheap shirt material that you feel you will rip by sneezing. However, the size of the shirt seems to be off by a size. I ordered an XL as usually I am comfortable to slightly snug in an XL. However the shirt that came had the label of an XL but was definitely a large. I find large too tight around my belly and this shirt was no difference. If I flexed, I could barely keep buttons from flying. Thankfully I have been wanting lose some weight and I am pretty sure I can fit this shirt once I hit my goal weight.
Color, fit, quality of construction all good. However, shirt is too stiff - as though it's one of those "no wrinkle" shirts, which I despise. Repeated washings - even with fabric softener - have not appreciably softened the hand of the fabric. Will keep, though, for cooler weather wearing.
I usually get a 2XL and I ordered a similar Wrangler Brand shirt when I bought this one. The Wrangler brand shirt fit as expected but the Goodthreads was a little snug. Not bad enough to return, but I am afraid to see how much it shrinks when washed.