To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
This is great quality shorts. Fit is perfect (I'm 5'7 145 lbs guy and I bought size Small). Not baggy not tight. No liner which I really like. However, I measured the inseam with a tape measure and it is closer to 8 inches than 7 inches. Even when worn high up the waist it is barely above knee. I don't want to wear it further up the waist otherwise the fabric will be rubbing against the balls. I wear Bonobo Core Shorts (Unlined) 7 inches inseam and they are my benchmarks for length and truly sits above knee.
I saw a couple reviews complaining that these were too tight around the waist but I took a chance on them anyway. Glad I did, they fit very well, waist is perfect... tight enough to hold them up without using the drawstring but not uncomfortable at all.
Was very difficult to find shorts that doesn't look like a loose skirt on me. I'm slim and short (5ft 7in), and these S size shorts fit me very well. Stays above my knees and not loose around my thighs.